What to expect
Visiting scholar Mark Walters (Queens University Law School) will be presenting his seminar, “Council Fire Constitutionalism: Reflections on Crown Honour and Indigenous Sovereignty”, as a part of the Victoria Colloquium series. Abstract: Writing for a unanimous Supreme Court of Canada in the recent case of Ontario v. Restoule, Justice Mahmud Jamal stated that provincial and federal governments must “act now” to respect treaty promises made to Indigenous nations in order to “restore the honour of the Crown and the nation-to-nation alliance that the treaties represent”; only by “return[ing] to the council fire”, he continued, will the crown demonstrate its “commitment to reconciliation.” The references to “honour” and “reconciliation” are not new in Canadian law, but the reference to “council fire” is. The Court’s judgment in Restoule is an example of a remarkable turn in Canadian jurisprudence: judges have begun to consider Indigenous legal traditions in the course of interpreting Crown-Indigenous relations. In this paper, I wish to explore the doctrinal and theoretical implications of these developments. In particular, I wish to consider whether the arguments advanced by James Tully, in his important book, Strange Multiplicity, in favour of an ‘agonistic’ constitutionalism, hold up in light of more recent developments in the discourses surrounding law, morality, and politics in Canada. Colloquium Reading: Council Fire Constitutionalism: Indigenous Legal Traditions and the Authority of the Canadian State. Mark D. Walters (2026) Pre-seminar reading that will be discussed: Toward the unity of constitutional value, or, how to capture a pluralistic hedgehog
The facts
- When
- Friday, November 64 p.m. to 5:30 p.m.
- Cost
- Not listed. Check with the organiser.
- Where
- Fraser Building (FRA)Oak Bay